Why Did NYC Mayor Mamdani Disband the Police Unit That Arrested Him Twice?

New videos and old photos show that New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani was zip-tied and taken away by officers from the NYPD Strategic Response Group at least twice before he became mayor. Now he has shut that same unit down. People are asking a simple question: was this about better police rules, or about what happened to him personally? The answer depends on who you ask, and the facts are easy to check.

Why Did NYC Mayor Mamdani Disband the Police Unit That Arrested Him Twice?

What the Videos Actually Show

On August 19, 2021, Mamdani was a New York State assemblyman. He joined a protest in Downtown Brooklyn. The crowd wanted the state to keep a rule that stopped landlords from forcing people out of homes during the COVID years. Police stopped the group. Mamdani himself posted a video that day. In it, an officer puts plastic ties on his wrists and walks him away. The officer’s vest clearly says “NYPD Strategic Response Group.” Mamdani wrote that he and fellow assembly member Marcela Mitaynes were among 17 people taken in. “We’re out now & we’ll keep fighting for these tenant protections,” he said.

A second time came in June 2024 outside Hunter College in Manhattan. Tenant groups were protesting rent rules. Local station ABC7 filmed the scene. The video shows Mamdani, then still an assemblyman, with his hands tied behind his back as officers lead him away. Again, the officers wear Strategic Response Group markings on their shoulders and backs. ABC7 did not name him at the time. Crain’s New York Business later matched the face and the uniforms. Crain’s reported the two incidents on November 18, 2026.

It is not clear if Mamdani was charged in either case. He has said he was arrested at protests four times in total before running for mayor. Only two of those times involved the Strategic Response Group, according to the Crain’s review of photos and video.

What the Strategic Response Group Was

The NYPD created the Strategic Response Group in 2015. Then-Commissioner William Bratton wanted a special team that could handle both terror threats and big protests or riots. The group had about 500 officers. They carried heavier gear, rode bikes in some cases, and trained for quick moves across the city. Officials said they were useful at large events, after shootings, and when crowds turned rough.

Critics saw a different side. After the 2020 protests over George Floyd’s death, lawsuits said the group used too much force. Pepper spray, mass arrests, and tight control of streets were common complaints. In 2023 the city settled some of those cases. Groups like the New York Civil Liberties Union said the unit treated everyday protests the same way it treated real terror risks. That mix, they argued, made officers more aggressive than needed.

Mamdani agreed with that view when he ran for mayor. He promised to end the unit. On November 16, 2026, he and Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch announced the change. Counter-terrorism work moves into the Intelligence and Counterterrorism Bureau. Protest work shifts to new teams: a civilian group that carries no guns and cannot make arrests, plus a smaller police team trained in talking and calming crowds. Mamdani said, “New Yorkers exercising their constitutional right to protest should not be met with the same police response as a terrorism threat.” CNN covered the announcement the same day.

Two Ways People See the Decision

One side says this is simple and fair. Mamdani spent years at protests. He saw how the unit worked up close. He made a clear promise during the campaign. Keeping that promise shows he does what he says. Supporters add that separating terror response from protest response makes sense on paper. A person holding a sign is not the same as a person planting a bomb. New civilian teams, they hope, will lower tension instead of raising it. Some posts on X after the Fox News video noted that the old clips may even help Mamdani with voters who like his style of politics.

The other side sees a personal score being settled. Mamdani was the one in the plastic ties. Months after the 2024 arrest he started his run for mayor and listed ending the unit as an early goal. Critics say a mayor should not erase a tool that once stopped him. Police unions called the move a step backward. They worry that big crowds or sudden violence will now meet slower or softer responses. Rank-and-file officers told reporters that the unit handled both protests and real emergencies, and breaking it up removes experience that took years to build. One reply under the Fox News post put it bluntly: he was arrested by them, so he got rid of them.

Neither side has a secret document that proves the other’s motive. The public record shows the arrests, the campaign promise, and the November 16 order. What a person thinks it means usually follows what they already believe about police and protests.

How the City Plans to Handle Protests Now

The new setup has several pieces. The Community Dialogue and De-escalation Division will sit in the mayor’s Office of Community Safety. Its members will be civilians. They will not carry weapons and will not have the power to arrest anyone. Their job is to talk with protest organizers before and during events. A smaller NYPD group called the First Amendment Support Team will start work sooner. About 30 officers will get extra training in communication. They will help manage peaceful gatherings until the civilian unit is fully ready, which could take a year or more. A Patrol Support Division will keep regular officers ready for larger needs.

Commissioner Tisch said the changes will not cut the number of officers or lower the city’s ability to answer serious threats. Counter-terrorism tools stay inside the police department. The goal, both officials said, is to match the response to the situation. Whether that works in practice will be tested the next time a large protest forms or a sudden emergency hits a busy street.

What People Are Saying Online and in Newsrooms

The Fox News post with the 2021 video drew hundreds of replies. Some called the move revenge. Others said a person who has been arrested for protest knows why the rules should change. A few noted that similar videos often make the politician more popular with his own voters. Mainstream outlets split along familiar lines. Outlets that favor police reforms highlighted the campaign promise and the lawsuits against the old unit. Outlets that focus on public order highlighted the personal history and the warnings from officers. Crain’s, which first dug up the matching footage, stuck to the timeline and the photos. The New York Post and Fox News stressed that the mayor never mentioned his own arrests when he announced the end of the unit.

On planet-today.com, readers have already seen related stories about Mamdani’s early moves in office. One recent piece looked at a billionaire selling a high-end New York apartment after Mamdani pushed a new tax on second homes: Ken Griffin Sells NYC Duplex for $58M After Mamdani Tax Video. Another covered an ally of the mayor being briefly held during a West Bank olive harvest. The pattern is the same: old actions and new power meet in public view, and people argue about what it shows.

The Open Questions That Remain

Will the new civilian teams keep streets calm when crowds grow large or turn angry? Will the officers who once worked in the Strategic Response Group carry the same skills into their new assignments? Did the two arrests shape the mayor’s view more than the wider record of lawsuits and complaints? No official paper answers those questions. The videos exist. The order to disband the unit exists. The rest is judgment.

Readers can watch the clips Mamdani posted in 2021 and the ABC7 footage from 2024. They can read the November 16 announcement and the Crain’s review. Then they can decide for themselves whether the change protects rights, settles a score, or does both at once.

Original source and date: The core reporting on the two arrests first appeared in Crain’s New York Business on November 18, 2026: https://www.crainsnewyork.com/politics-policy/cny-mamdani-srg-arrests-20261118/. The People’s Voice published a version of the story on November 21, 2026: https://thepeoplesvoice.tv/mamdani-arrested-twice-nypd-counterterrorism-unit-disbanding/. Fox News posted the 2021 video on X on November 20, 2026.

Disclaimer for fact-checkers: The arrests and the disbanding are confirmed by multiple outlets including Crain’s New York Business, the New York Post, Fox News, and CNN. The People’s Voice has published inaccurate stories in the past. This article relies on the primary reporting and public videos rather than any single secondary source. Readers should check the original footage and official statements for themselves.

Post a Comment

What do you think? Share your opinion below – every comment matters! Please be respectful. Spamming or advertising is not allowed.

Previous Post Next Post

Independent desk. No ads. If you stay to the end, the donate link is there.

Follow us on TruthSocial, X-Twitter, Gettr, Gab, VK, Anonup, Facebook and Telegram for interesting and mysterious bonus content!

This piece took hours to check against the primary record. Planet Today has no corporate desk and no ad network behind it. If it was useful, $5 keeps the next one free to read.

Support Planet Today

Contact form

Radio